- D. All of above names are used to describe non-taxable
exchanges under IRS Code. They all refer to same type of transaction.
- C. The Form (IRS Form 8824) is called "Like-Kind Exchange".
It is form that is filed when an exchange is consummated.
- D. A direct exchange is extremely rare. In this transaction
two owners would exchange and keep each others
properties. Normally, in this method one of owners
would have some tax to pay.
In a simultaneous exchange, owner "A" wanting a Tax-Deferred
Exchange would release their property to party "C". At
same time, owner "B" would release their property to owner "A".
An experienced escrow holder is needed to insure that pro-
party "B" would be deeded directly to owner "A" while property
"A" would be deeded to owner "B" who would deed it to party C.
Some transactions involve more than three properties and could be
called, for example, a six Legged Exchange, etc., and all
escrows are closed simultaneously. This is chaos unlimited with
many agents, owners, sellers, buyers, escrows, attorneys and
CPAs involved.
- A. In a traditional 1031 Exchange, owner desiring a
tax-deferred (like-kind) exchange is called taxpayer
or owner "A". Their property is called downleg property.
upleg property is higher-valued property that they
desire. upleg property owner (owner "B") will normally
have some tax to pay. In most cases, they don't want pro-
party "A", so that is sold to owner "C" so "B" is disposing
of their property.
- A. Statement of fact from IRS Code. For an explanation of
like-kind, see question 6.
- D. This is right out of IRS Code Section.
- B. Real estate rentals of all types are considered
business properties. Most real estate investors and agents
believe that rentals are Investment Property. No so. It
is better to have them classified as Business Properties
for IRS purposes
because losses and interest payments are easier to deduct.
In my experiences, only investment property that I have
encountered is raw land.
- D. And many more.
- A, B, C, D, E, G, I. Like-kind has a wide definition.
Almost all real estate qualifies except personal residences
and vacation homes. Also, C illustrates that more
than one property can be exchanged for a single property.
Answer F is incorrect because 1031 Exchanges can't be made
with foreign property of any type. This is different than
the Section 121. $250K and $500K Personal Residence Exclusion
because a taxpayer can sell a foreign persons residence and get
exclusion.
Answers H and I show that question of whether property
is like-kind is based in how I will use property, not
its present use.
Business Machinery is not like-kind with real estate. How-
ever, you can do a tax-deferred exchange of Business
Machinery for Business Machinery but that is another story.
Limited partnership interests are not like-kind with an
apartment house. However, an apartment house owned by a
partnership could be exchanged for other like-kind
property.
- A. If a buyer doesn't want to wait for owner to find
an upleg property, property can be sold and money
would go to a third party who would hold money until
owner finds right property. There are many rules
on these Tax Deferred Exchanges. Some of topics are
addressed in some extra questions that are on our Web site,
http://www.DuaneGomer.com.
- B. To accomplish a delayed exchange, a taxpayer can't receive
control of money. Therefore it must go directly from the escrow
company processing a sale of any downleg property to an appointed
intermediary.
- B. Statement of fact.
- D. It is recommended that a prospective exchanger start selecting
an upleg property or properties as soon as feasible. If possible, a
long escrow period should be demanded in any downleg sale. I believe
strongly that you should try t designate and close any upleg purchase
in the 45 day period to be sure of IRS compliance.
- A. Most investors know the 45 day designation rule but they believe
that you have 180 days to close any new purchase. That is not
true. You have 180 days or until the due date of your tax return including
extensions. For example, you close a downleg sale on December 31st.
Like
most people your tax return is due April 15. The period from December 31
to April 15 is 105 days most years and 106 days in a leap year. If you
haven't closed your upleg escrow by April 15, you best request an automatic
extension. If you don't, you would lose your deferment of gain.
Why does IRS they have this rule? With this regulation when you file your tax
return, you will know whether you can file a Like-Kind Exchange Form 8824
or not. Either you have an exchange or you don't. Some taxpayers have
filed their tax return on time only to find out their exchange is not
completed so it can't be recognized. That presents some "real problems".
- D. Pick an accommadator carefully. There have been many cases of
accommodators disappearing with funds of from 1031 exchanges. It is strongly
recommended that you use a professional, well-funded, experienced, bonded,
corporate entity. Picking a private party could prove to be a problem in case
of death, financial problems, bankruptcy, etc. Parties who have had their money
stolen are shocked to discover that they now owe tax on their sale because they
didn't consummate an exchange.
- A. Statement of fact.
- A. If you complete an exchange with more real estate and more
liabilities and
you receive no boot, you can be certain you will have no tax liability, according
to Counselor Starr from Oakland who wrote this concept on a napkin during
lunch and used this concept in his many lectures and writings.
- D. If a taxpayer refinances before or after a exchange, cash could be
extracted from their equities and if done properly there would be no tax if
an exchange was completed. Doing a refinance as part of an exchange
transaction could cause refinance proceeds to be classified as cash boot
(not a good thing). There are no set limits in the code on how long before
or after an exchange a refinance must be completed so talk to many experts
including a tax attorney, a CPA, an accomodater, a lender, an escrow
officer, a title officer, an exchange specialist, broker, etc., as soon as possible
even before listing any property.
- B. Purchasing an upleg property before selling your downleg property is
called a Reverse Exchange. Most professionals use term a "Reverse Starker
Exchange" recognizing T. J. Starker, an Oregon lumberland owner, who
challenged the IRS and received tax deferment on an exchange in 1969. His
exchange had no time limits so the IRS established Safe Harbor Rules,
for traditional downleg and upleg exchanges. Many professionals started
doing Reverse Exchanges
because they were not discussed in original Safe Harbor Rules. Consequently,
in November 2000, the IRS established Safe Harbor Rules for Reverse Exchanges
which are the same time limits and receipt requirements as traditional
exchanges, For more information on Reverse Exchanges, go to our Web site and
check the Reverse Exchange article.
- D. When you do an exchange, you postpone tax on the gain from the sale
of your downleg property. There has to be a method of keeping score. The IRS
insists that you calculate your gain and subtract it from the value of your
new property.
To illustrate with an over-simplified exchange with no fees, costs, commissions,
etc. "A" has a piece of land worth $10,000 and "B" has land worth $40,000. "A's" basis
is $3,000 and "B's" basis is $22,000. "A" will give "B" his land plus $30.000 in cash.
"A's" nonrecognized gain is $7,000. This would be deducted from the $40,000 fair
market value of his new property, so his basis in the new property would be $33,000.
(This is the last line on the Form 8824. If you have ever done an exchange in the
past, go back to your tax return and check the basis of your acquired property at
the close of escrow. If there is no Form 8824, call your tax preparer and find
out why. If you did your own return and there is no Form 8824, fire yourself as
your tax preparer). Incidentally, "B" would have tax to pay on his gain of $18,000,
which is the lesser of gain ($18,000) versus boot received ($30,000).
For information on recommended sources of outstanding materials on exchanges,
e-Mail,
Phone, Fax, or Write to our office. Complete contact information is listed
below.